
Keri Nicholson | Luxury Real Estate Specialist & International Diamond Society Awardee
Experience the Best of Maui Real Estate
Keri Nicholson brings a unique blend of East Coast work ethic and deep-rooted Maui island knowledge to Coldwell Banker Island Properties. Originally from Topsfield, Massachusetts, Keri traded the hectic Atlantic winters for the serene pace of the Pacific. Her transition into real estate was a natural evolution of her passion for people and her years of experience as a premier West Maui concierge.
Award-Winning Service
Keri’s commitment to excellence has recently earned her the prestigious 2025 International Diamond Society award. This honor recognizes her as one of the top sales professionals within the global Coldwell Banker network, a testament to her dedication, market expertise, and "client-first" philosophy.
A Foundation of Excellence
Mentored by her aunt, a top-producing Realtor in Vail, Colorado, Keri possesses a sophisticated understanding of luxury markets and resort properties. Whether you are a first-time homebuyer, looking for a vacation retreat, or selling a slice of paradise, Keri’s diverse background allows her to navigate the Maui market with precision and care.
Life Beyond the Sale
When she isn’t helping clients find their dream homes, Keri is an adventurer at heart. She has visited all 50 U.S. states and is an avid sailor and skier. For Keri, real estate is more than a career—it’s an opportunity to ensure no two days are ever the same while helping others plant roots in the place she now calls home.
"I tried several agents before selecting Keri. I wanted an investment vacation rental condo which requires a lot of information and team to execute. Most agents will set you up on MLS and accept and transmit a bid. As to working with you and being responsive to your needs (vs repeatedly calling and asking you to make a bid), not so much. However, Keri actually helped me with the unit research and purchase and introduced me to her contacts so I could make an informed purchase and actually get to closing successfully." ~ Gary
"Absolutely thrilled that we ran into Keri at an open house in Maui one day while we were on vacation last year. She is extremely knowledgeable not only about the area, but about each individual complex. It is very important to us that a realtor not simply send us deals, but keep us personally informed on what is coming available. Keri is just that kind of realtor! She really took her time and was very patient with us in our search. It took over 8 months, but we finally landed not one, but two contracts! We truly felt like we got insider information! But the service didn't stop there, Keri and her team kept us informed every step of the way. One word to sum up how we feel about Keri is "Trustworthy". We highly recommend using her and her team to find your forever home/investment! If you want to be on top of today's market, trust Keri to keep you there!" ~P.M.
"Keri and Lee are the perfect blend of personable and professional. Lee helped guide Missy and I on our journey of buying of Maui 3-years ago and when the time came to sell and move to our next project, Lee introduced us to Keri. Keri was able to negotiate us a price on our condo that far exceeded our expectations, she then made sure the sale went smoothly and trouble free. When the time comes to buy or sell on Maui, Keri will be my first call! Mahalo Keri!
"Keri recently sold our property in Lahaina! I can't say enough about the fabulous service and attention to detail that they provided for our family in the course of the sale. Keri Nicholson went above and beyond. She kept us informed of all the details and complications that arose and took care of everything as we did not live on island. I highly recommend this marvelous group if you are looking to sell your property!" ~ Nancy
"Keri Nicholson did a wonderful job finding us a dream condo right on Kaanapali Beach. This process took us 4+ years of Maui trips reviewing countless numbers of listings to finally determine the right location for us. Keri was so patient and understanding in showing us so many properties. I don't think there was a condo property on the west side of Maui we didn't visit and look at a unit or two. Keri also kept consistent touch with us while in the mainland, always making sure we saw any new listings. On a couple of occasions, she would visit a property in our absence and hold a FaceTime meeting so we could see the condo while away. Absolutely outstanding. We will definitely use her again!!" ~ Kevin
"My wife and I went to Maui April 2021, and we were looking to buy a condo on maui. We walked into the office of Keri Nicholson. That was a gift. Keri took the time to help us find a condo. She drove us around, picked us up at our resort and showed us several different areas and different units. We were doing a 1031 exchange and were still several months away from closing, and Keri is very good doing 1031. We had to back to the mainland. We kept in touch and Keri sent different properties available. Finally when we were close to closing the 1031, Keri found us a great condo. We closed escrow on our Maui condo 3 weeks ago. Thank you Keri for a great job. I highly recommend Keri and her associates if you want great service and someone who really cares, then call Keri Nicholson." ~ Dave

















